FANDOM

9,379 Pages

(reply)
Line 2: Line 2:
   
 
: I'm against listing appearances for this (and other frequently-appearing places). The appearances template was originally for characters for a reason. A room like this, I would assume, was in the majority of episodes, and if not, it was visible in the background or nearby. Would we say it didn't ''appear'' if the camera wasn't inside it, filming a meeting? That strikes me as arbitrary. Would we list it every time it was visible at all? I don't think that would be a useful thing to catalogue, either. – [[User:Blue Rook|Blue Rook]] 21:41, 30 May 2008 (UTC)<sub>[[User talk:Blue Rook|<font color="skyblue">talk</font>]][[Special:Contributions/Blue Rook|contribs]]</sub>
 
: I'm against listing appearances for this (and other frequently-appearing places). The appearances template was originally for characters for a reason. A room like this, I would assume, was in the majority of episodes, and if not, it was visible in the background or nearby. Would we say it didn't ''appear'' if the camera wasn't inside it, filming a meeting? That strikes me as arbitrary. Would we list it every time it was visible at all? I don't think that would be a useful thing to catalogue, either. – [[User:Blue Rook|Blue Rook]] 21:41, 30 May 2008 (UTC)<sub>[[User talk:Blue Rook|<font color="skyblue">talk</font>]][[Special:Contributions/Blue Rook|contribs]]</sub>
  +
  +
I see what you are saying. It wouldn't work for something that is in the background for nearly every episode. However, I think Tech 1 is one that could have an appearances template for, because it is not in it as much, as if it is, it ''obviously'' is. But maybe it would be better to keep it so that if we don't have it for one, we don't have it for any. [[User:SignorSimon|SignorSimon]] 21:45, 30 May 2008 (UTC)

Revision as of 21:45, May 30, 2008

This page needs a lot more information, specifially it needs work on the appearances template. I'm watching S3 at the minute, but if anyone else can cover the other seasons, that would be great. SignorSimon 21:37, 30 May 2008 (UTC)

I'm against listing appearances for this (and other frequently-appearing places). The appearances template was originally for characters for a reason. A room like this, I would assume, was in the majority of episodes, and if not, it was visible in the background or nearby. Would we say it didn't appear if the camera wasn't inside it, filming a meeting? That strikes me as arbitrary. Would we list it every time it was visible at all? I don't think that would be a useful thing to catalogue, either. – Blue Rook 21:41, 30 May 2008 (UTC)talkcontribs

I see what you are saying. It wouldn't work for something that is in the background for nearly every episode. However, I think Tech 1 is one that could have an appearances template for, because it is not in it as much, as if it is, it obviously is. But maybe it would be better to keep it so that if we don't have it for one, we don't have it for any. SignorSimon 21:45, 30 May 2008 (UTC)

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.